Friday, May 16, 2008
Don’t say the ‘M’ word
Posted by the mad momma under Uncategorized | Tags: cribs, issues |[12] Comments
I just read this and this and since I as usual had so much to say - I have turned back to my own blog instead of hogging their space. To begin with - I *so* agree.
Incase you haven’t read the links, we’re talking periods here. I mean hey.. we’ve discussed breastfeeding and pooping babies and circumcision. Why not rush in further where angels fear to tread?
As both the women in the posts I’ve linked to mentioned, women of even our generation have been given every freedom but the one that allows them into religious places when they have their period. I don’t get it.
Yes, I am aware of the old logic that this was the only time a woman was given rest and so they called her impure and told her not to come out of her room. Puja was a lengthy affair and required much effort so she was excused from that also. But that then got twisted further and soon moved on to other things. If a menstruating woman touches the pickles/jams - they get spoilt. So no working with preserves, yes, again, I know it was hard work and it was a way of excusing them.
But now we know better don’t we? We know that if a woman wants rest she can have it and if she wants to continue with her regular work she will. How about giving them the freedom and the choice to get up and be normal or lie down and rest depending on how they feel?
Today we have pain medication, tampons and pads with wings- just about every option being advertised loudly and boldly, so that women are comfortable. And menstruating women are climbing mountains, doing surgery, working in NASA and God alone what else - but *still* not allowed into temples and churches. So for God’s sake - how about giving that old superstition a well deserved retirement? It served its purpose and went on to be abused and misused. Its time we put it to bed. Firmly.
Long ago there was this time when I didn’t get up to take communion in Church. Dad glared at me since he was half way up the aisle. Caused a bit of a disturbance by stopping midway and walking back to our pew to ask me what was wrong. Told him why I wasn’t coming. He didn’t think twice about giving me the dirtiest look. And then right there, in Church, in the hushed silence he ripped into me and told me that I am not to perpetuate anymore of this nonsense. Errr. okay.
Some people are surprised at that. But our family converted some 5 generations ago and some of the old Hindu customs lived on. That said, no community is free from its hang ups. I once went to Church in a saree with a bindi on. The Priest turned me away from the altar without communion - saying that my Bindi was a Hindu symbol and I shouldn’t wear it to Church. I went back to my pew with tears in my eyes. Dad was so mad he almost socked the Priest. And his family unfortunately stood by the Priest’s dictats. We didn’t ever go back to worship there. I don’t believe God can live in the midst of ignorance and superstition and hatred of another’s customs. That the thali that most South Indian Christians wear is an adaptation of the Hindu mangalsutra is not even an argument we got into with the Priest. I don’t think he was worthy of our time and attention.
Getting back to the period thing. And the rest - I wear gold anklets. Always have. My mother did too. And time and again I have been told gold is not worn on the feet unless you are a Rajput. Fair enough. (Well not so fair - what makes it okay for the Rajputs to wear it?!) That is their call. But is it fair to foist that on those who don’t believe it? My maid drove me nuts. Everytime she walked into the house to do the dishes, she’d see my anklets since I was in shorts and would get very upset and want me to take them off. Once some random idiot on the train caught a glimpse of my anklets under my jeans and decided to tell me that I was committing a sin. Strong words. She gave me the story that gold is precious. Hence to be worshipped and must not be worn on the feet.
Well - maybe you don’t want to wear it on your feet, but why stop me? I am not forcing you to wear it. Maybe some communities believe in a veil or a hijaab. Would you like that to be forced on you?
What is it that makes feet so unworthy of respect? Why is it okay to touch books with your hands and not your feet? (I’ve done two posts on feet. I must dig them up.) They are all body parts and worthy of my respect. Even the body part that shoots my babies out. Truly. All made by the God we all so fervently worship and like to blame our ignorance on.
The best I can think of here is that in the old days people didn’t have proper footwear and feet were dirty and cracked. So, don’t put them on clean beds or books or any other place that needs to be kept clean. But what is the problem today? Why are feet treated like poor cousins? Mine are clean and soft and well maintained. More than my face at the best of times. So?
Many like to argue that it’s simpler not to argue with people and just do it to keep them happy. I think that is the wrong way to look at it. You’re perpetuating superstition and forcing the next generation of people to believe this nonsense too. Teaching our boys that there is something wrong with periods. Teaching our girls that its something to be ashamed of.
I remember a friend whose mother would make her get up at the crack of dawn and wash out stained sheets and underwear so that her father and brother didn’t know she was having her period. And she was not supposed to lie back in bed and show that something was wrong. Now that to me is the other extreme. Her mother told her it would be extremely shameful to get up in the morning and for her father or brother to find out that she had her period. Errrr… why? What is wrong with her period I wanted to know. Wouldn’t it be abnormal if she never had one? Wouldn’t *that* be a problem?
And on the other hand I had this nice family friend - a guy, whose mother would send give him money on the way to school to buy sanitary napkins on the way back, for her and his sister. And he grew up to be so kind and considerate. Getting a hot water bottle, buying some chocolate on the way back - this a teenage boy. I hope to be able to bring up my son to be that considerate.
Don’t fuss said my mother and grandmother. You don’t need medicine. I would cramp and be in agony and not say a word. The moment I knew I was getting married, I said, to hell with mother and grandmother, I am now out of their home. I had a check up and was found to have cysts. No wonder the agony. And nobody bothered with me because that is how it was meant to be. We were meant to be stoic. The upside is that I can bear any amount of pain now and you will never see me lie down, pop a pill or complain.
And this is what bothers me. The extremes. Either you are thrown in a dark room, not allowed to worship, touch preservatives and do a dozen other things depending on what community you belong to. Or you are told to act normal and pretend nothing is wrong. Don’t complain. Don’t take an afternoon nap. Don’t mention that you are having what is normal and happens every month. Just stay mum and suffer. Or then be discriminated against.
And that is when I get into arguments with friends. Over discretion being the better part of valour. Not in this case, no thank you. Not for me. Don’t stay quiet. Don’t let it pass. Don’t be a part of something so unfair, so archaic, so sexist. Do you strongly believe that it’s unfair? Then stand up for what you believe in. Never mind old ladies and mothers and grandmothers and MILs and SILs and hurting their feelings. I think its a bigger issue than a few hurt feelings.
I have a daughter. I will not be allowing her anywhere where restrictions are placed on her during her periods. If she is not good enough to be welcome during her periods, I am afraid that place is not good enough for her at all. Because I am not passing on any message to her that says this is something to be ashamed of, afraid of or to lie about. To her grandmother, her friend’s mother or any place of worship.
What amazes me is that it took my father to stand up for me before anything came of it - a man. It has so long been considered a woman’s issue that you won’t see men getting involved. And that is what I want for my Bean. I want the men in our family to make sure she is treated well too. So if she is unwelcoe in some place during her periods - not just she or I but even my son and my husband will not be bothered with such places or people. We will stand by the right to be treated equally and fairly as a family.














